Olave (2022) received rookie of the year votes, You could make an argument for Alonte Taylor(2022) and Paulson Adebo (2021). Eric Mccoy (2019) is a pro-bowler. I would argue Ceedy Deuce (2019) is a league recognized star.
Most teams don't draft a "bona fide league-recognized star" every year.
Olave cost 3 draft picks, but he has no YAK, so he'll never be a true star. Adebo is good. Alontae is athletic but misses too many tackles and maakes bone headed mistakes to leave people wide open