Sun Wukong
Kicker's, Inc. Superfan
Online
I feel ya there. For me, I thought Garfield was the perfect Peter Parker even if he wasn't the best Spider-Man. He illustrated most of the traits I expected to see from Peter. Maguire was just meh and Holland is just too childish for my liking.
I agree. Quality of movies aside (they were junk), Garfield was a great choice for the character.
I've always found Tobey Maguire to come across as a doofy creep.