[Thursday Update: Winston not at practice] Winston not at practice. Taysom Hill taking QB snaps today.[Update 2: Rehabing Back, Ankle & Hip] (1 Viewer)

[Taker597]

How does Winston's playoff record compare to Dalton's?

He doesn't have any. That's literally better than Dalton.

 

[Judge_Smails]

Your sarcasm detection is at unparalleled levels.

Your ability to execute sarcasm and humor is less than Jameis’ ability to play QB with a broken back.

 

[Saint Taysom]

He doesn't have any. That's literally better than Dalton.

How is that better?
Jameis has never led a team to a playoff appearance!

Dalton has led his team to appearances, but those haven’t gone well.

I’ll take the guy that’s been there vs the guy that can’t

 

[StudioSaint]

He doesn't have any. That's literally better than Dalton.

Seems irrational to me to think that the QB that hasn't even managed to make it to playoffs gives the Saints a better chance in the playoffs than the QB that's managed to make it to the playoffs more than once.

I think the reasonable thought is that it's unknown at this time whether Winston or Dalton would give the Saints the best chance in the playoffs.

 

[Taker597]

How is that better?
Jameis has never led a team to a playoff appearance!

Dalton has led his team to appearances, but those haven’t gone well.

I’ll take the guy that’s been there vs the guy that can’t

Seems irrational to me to think that the QB that hasn't even managed to make it to playoffs gives the Saints a better chance in the playoffs than the QB that's managed to make it to the playoffs more than once.

I think the reasonable thought is that it's unknown at this time whether Winston or Dalton would give the Saints the best chance in the playoffs.

Historically speaking... A bad playoff QB don't become a great one. That's probably the only thing that goes in Winston favor. Winston is a decent QB when he plays healthy and an Elite defense can carry a healthy Winston. No elite team can carry a hurt QB or an Andy Dalton.

Nothing Personal. Andy should start so that we can get Winston healthy. A Healthy Winston was better than Old Dalton all camp.

 

[black_floyd]

Your ability to execute sarcasm and humor is less than Jameis’ ability to play QB with a broken back.

It's always funny to see a stranger butt into something that had nothing to do with them and get butthurt on someone else's behalf when that person just couldn't pick up on dry humor to begin with.

 

[Judge_Smails]

It's always funny to see a stranger butt into something that had nothing to do with them and get butthurt on someone else's behalf when that person just couldn't pick up on dry humor to begin with.

My butt is not hurt or even moderately sore. Don’t say dumb things that set yourself up if you don’t want comments from the peanut gallery. This is like, the internet. Not the Rotary.

 

[black_floyd]

My butt is not hurt or even moderately sore. Don’t say dumb things that set yourself up if you don’t want comments from the peanut gallery. This is like, the internet. Not the Rotary.

You seem to be the only one taking this seriously lol.

 

[BreesIsMyFather]

Bad news fellas.

If the team isnt letting him rest, someone is stubborn as hell…. I hope he’s good to go, if so. Ughhhh

 

[Judge_Smails]

You seem to be the only one taking this seriously lol.

It’s not serious for me. I just have better material than you do.

 

[SigFreudianSlip]

Jameis is the black knight from The Quest For The Holy Grail.

 

[black_floyd]

It’s not serious for me. I just have better material than you do.

It's just funny because you came to me, not the other way around, and pretty clearly need the last word in this so feel free to have your internet argument participation trophy if that's what you need.

 

[StudioSaint]

Historically speaking... A bad playoff QB don't become a great one. That's probably the only thing that goes in Winston favor. Winston is a decent QB when he plays healthy and an Elite defense can carry a healthy Winston. No elite team can carry a hurt QB or an Andy Dalton.

Nothing Personal. Andy should start so that we can get Winston healthy. A Healthy Winston was better than Old Dalton all camp.

Only time can tell if Dalton or Winston gives the Saints the best chance in the playoffs. Neither one may get a chance.

The bolded part seems to be an interesting twist. Winston has been downgraded to Dilfer's level now?

 

[Quiet Storm]

None of that is necessarily true
Plant foot is certainly effected- all muscles compensate for injury then they have to unlearn the compensation and relearn the ‘normal’ way or learn a new normal
And he can still have the strength to throw but the back compromises accuracy and speed

It was even said during the game last week that Winston said the back is affecting is plant foot. I mean it's kinda clear. The dude was hitting those deep shots last year and now he's not even close.

 

[Taker597]

Only time can tell if Dalton or Winston gives the Saints the best chance in the playoffs. Neither one may get a chance.

The bolded part seems to be an interesting twist. Winston has been downgraded to Dilfer's level now?

Right now... Winston is an injury prone QB. I say that's worse.