Would you take tainted Super Bowls? (1 Viewer)

[Jonesy77]

3 Saints Superbowl wins, but under suspician of cheating or same old Saints?

 

[primadox]

I'd take the same old Saints. No question. At least they'd be more loveable!

 

[Bill]

I'll take our few legit wins over Patriot-style wins any day!

And if any of our past wins have come about by cheating... I wouldn't want 'em either.

 

[Nonreg]

ill take the superbowls.

 

[d3vanj]

No. I am 100% against cheating on ANY scale, especially in a big game like that..

 

[Jackavelli]

i'm not gonna question anyone's inner beliefs on cheating, but if I hear someone say they do not want a Saints SB if the Saints tape another team; I would have a hard time thinking they are a Saints Fan.

 

[Skip Bayless]

Umm....

I don't care

we've been in the league for a looong time with only 2 playoff wins

we're the most pathetic team in the NFL

give me a ring

 

[baarbogast]

I want the rings, there hasn';t been any proof the Pats cheated so their wins aren't tainted. I want evidence not just someone saying they supposedly did something during a walkthrough.

 

[saintsfan342000]

As a Dallas Stars fan, I am obligated to take tainted championships.

 

[marccooper]

Our current regime is tainted with staff who cannot identify the next Wes Welker (we made a trade with Miami too, for Mare), get production out of vets like Seau who people thought was finished, turn a middle round pick into an Asante Samuel, scrap together top secondaries out of middle round picks altogether, get production out of a cocky player like Randy Moss, etc. I would rather a regime that maybe cheated a little than a regime that lacks the coaching and talent evaluation ability, particularly on the defensive side of the ball, to make cheating worth the effort. We need to view Belichick as a model, not discount his success.

 

[Bill]

I want the rings, there hasn';t been any proof the Pats cheated so their wins aren't tainted. I want evidence not just someone saying they supposedly did something during a walkthrough.

What a mean, cruel new league commissioner we have now who would fine a coach and pull a first round pick for unsubstantiated rules violations.

:dunno: /sarcasm off

 

[Bill]

We need to view Belichick as a model, not discount his success.

I smell another upcoming pro wrestling league. :yellowsighw:

 

[Eeyore]

Take three championships because the Saints outsmart the competition or accept losing... Hmmmmmm

 

[zmonbobbo]

By "same old Saints," does that mean we'd never win one, or we'd have to work hard and maybe we'd eventually get one? If I knew there was no other way, I'd take the tainted titles, but if there was even a shred of hope that we could still win it all the right way, I'd say don't cheat.

 

[bop]

there hasn';t been any proof the Pats cheated

I voted for taking the rings, but are you serious? No proof? Really? Wow.