Woodford Reserve or Maker's Mark?

Makers Mark or Weller Special Reserve would be a good place to start. It probably depends on what your current drink of choice is. If you like the sweet stuff like wine, Then maybe an Evan Williams would be better for you. If you dig brandy, then Weller or the 1792 might be a better choice.

I've already said it once on here, but it is worth mentioning twice: Eagle Rare is probably the best bourbon for the buck that I have ever had. Very smooth, not too sweet. Knob Creek is what I drink the most. K&B if you can get your hands on it.