Or Benry plays semantics and gets Jack off the island -- the "Alcatraz" island -- and returns him to Locke et al. (Jack still doesn't know does he? And the deal was made on the new island wasn't it?)
Yep, that's what I was thinking when Benry made the agreement. Jack doesn't know he's on a different island from the one he crashed onto. What was the point of the voice telling Jack that the door was open? So that he'd see Kate and Sawyer? :shrug: