Evidence for God

The fundamental implied assumption made in that entire argument is that God was incapable of violating/altering the laws of Physics in any such way and still have a universe conducive to life.

Which is simply outright wrong logic. If God is omniscent and omnipresent, which all Christians assert, then he could have, in fact, arranged the universe in any such way as he wanted. The question then, for Christians, is not "how could a universe so precisely set be anything but evidence of God" but rather "why would God choose to precisely set the universe in such a manner?".

The incredibly expansive, tenuously balanced universe is not evidence of intelligent design, it is, actually, evidence of the lack of intelligent design.