Evidence for God
One popular question I have heard posed to Atheists is:
"If there is no intelligent creator, then why is there something rather than nothing?"
If you can't answer that question, you're probably more of an Agnostic than an Atheist, and in my mind, a step in the right direction.
The anthropic principle rears its head in every one of these discussions. I find it infuriating. The problem is the assumption that someone/thing had to create everything. Maybe everything just IS. Do you really think you understand what it means for something to BE? I don't. And I don't think you do either.
The question of whether we have an intelligent creator, and the determination of the meaning of life, are two different discussions. Science deals with everything back to a millionth of a nanosecond after the Big Bang. Before that is not a concern (to science).
So there are not only two opinions here. It seems everyone on this board either believes there is no God and nothing happens when you die, or God created everyone and everything 6,000 years ago, disguised everything to look like it came from evolution, then hid the dinosaur bones and created DNA just to trick us.
One more thing that irritates me. Agnostic does not mean you do not care if there is a God. Agnostic = lack of knowledge. It means you believe, rather sensibly, that we are not capable of understanding the divine nature of our universe. It means that I'd love to know, I just don't, and I can't. I don't try to figure out God, just like penguins don't discuss quantum physics.
EDIT: To clarify, I AM agnostic. Meaning: I believe primarily in science, but I'm open to the idea that someone or something created the laws that science and physics must abide by. There are things that we can't understand that are attributed to a god. But there are also things we DO understand, that we can prove empirically, that don't make sense in a random universe. See the Uncertainty Principle.