Madden Jinx
http://sports.espn.go.com/videogames/index
You have to click the link on "The Contenders" to get a pop-up. But ESPN says they are leaning toward Peyton, at 7-2 odds.
The list is as follows:
Manning: 7:2
Brady: 5:1
Chad Johnson
LT
Bush
VY
Sorry I got sick of looking up the odds on the article.