NFL gave Vilma a sworn affidavit from Gregg Williams stating Vilma offered $10k to knock out Favre

krushing said

I wonder why vilma doesn't take polygraph from a highly respect testing group and challenge the two coaches to do same. They'd look like complete liars if he did that. I think it would totally force almost all public opinion to his side and totally embarrass the nfl

Click to expand...

They could all be honest.

Vilma did or said something which according to Vilma and 8 others was not a pledge to injure whereas as Cerullo and GW see it, do constitute a pledge to injure.

For example, when a coach scream at a player to stick that guy private part into the ground, the coach is honest when he made a declaration that he never told any player to castrate another player whereas another person who heard that would be honest when he said that coach wanted the player to castrate another player.

Now, solicitation of castration of another person is a horrendous crime. That is definitely conduct detrimental.

If words without context constitute a crime, then the entire NFL needs to be suspended.

I called it slicing the salami too thin to infer there was a pledge to injure when no payment was made for what happened to Warner/Favre, because those 2 sure did get knocked around and carted off.