Yeah, how can a player be simultaneously compared to an All Pro and a total bust?
I can understand the Kearse comparison based on size to speed ratio, but Kearse was way heavier at 260 to 272 lbs. Mingo is listed at 240 lbs and that might be generous.
The one thing I worry about with Mingo is wearing down due to his slender frame and not being able to rely on pure speed at the next level. I've watched his progress since he was here in West Monroe and he still seems to be the same size he was in high school. Seems like he can't gain or keep weight on.
Monty on the other hand is already 260 and ready to compete for a starting job. He doesn't have the God given speed that Mingo has but he's more complete and has a motor that doesn't stop.