Todd McShay the most accurate mock drafter over the last 3 years

Also keep in mind, every "scout" or "analyst" sees things a bit differently. They are all using what they hear from others to shape their opinion, but I honestly believe Kiper and Mayock look at film themselves and see what they do and don't like. I know I've heard Mayock mention certain key measurables (like hands on a QB) that help him frame his opinion.

I've always found McShay to just be a guy who's a good synthesizer of information. It's like he's like a lot of us on here. Just smart enough on football, but really good and taking what others say, break it down, and organize it. Maybe he just comes off a certain way, but I've never been a huge fan. For whatever reason the online draftnik community does not care for McShay.

And again, averages are a horrible way to look at this data (it was done a year ago, btw, doesn't include the 2012 draft)

EDIT: Derp... gotta read the second link.. haha. that one has 2012 in it.