I think those threads are inevitable no matter who we pick, frankly. :covri:
I'm sure saintaholic is a pretty safe bet to start the first one if Jones is our pick, though. :hihi:
As to the original argument, all I can say is it's very lame and reminds me greatly of monkey logic.
For those who aren't acquainted with monkey logic, here's an example:
All fish live in water,
Whales live in water,
Therefore, whales are fish.
In other words, taking one particular piece of information and ignoring everything else to reach a conclusion.