Loved the new BSG.. The show doesn't have much rewatchability for me. Except maybe the rescue from New Caprica.. Because I know all the surprise moments ahead of time. I liked the ending of the series, but so much goes unanswered it seems.
i don 't think "plot" (surprise elements and the like) is really the strong element of BSG
small arcs (what's going to happen with Gatea, what happens when Helo finds out, the in and out relationship of the Adamas and Lee & Starbuck)
ALL the political intrigue
ALL the psychological intrigue (what does it mean to be sane? human? spiritual?)
etc etc
being chased by cylons, will they find new caprica, will the mutiny work???
those are just excuses to get to some really profound stuff