Au contraire, mon ami. Right now Eli's spot on various career records:
Passing TDs: 7th
Passing yards: 9th
Passes completed: 8th
He's ahead of both Rivers and Rothlisberger, who each started the same year. He has two SB wins where he was a major contributor (Ben, not so much the first time, Mr. 10-23 + major ref help). And he's done it all playing in one of the windiest stadiums in the league. And in maybe THE toughest media market for a quarterback.
After than Tom and Drew, Eli has to be next. The rest of those guys don't have as much up on the wall (although Rothlisberger is probabaly a lock at this point as well), and if Rodgers doesn't get his act together, ultimately he may fall short as well.