Pontiac Fiero versus Toyota MR2

I can't really cite personal experience for these specific models but I drove a 1985 Supra (with the inimitable 2-tone gray/gray paint job) for 7 years--a great car for someone in their 20s. (Sold it to a friend's sister for cash in 1993, and a few months later some idiot plowed into it from behind while she had it legally parked on the street and totalled it. Very sad.)

So it would be hard for me to pick against Toyota of that era.