He's had a garbage team most of his career and a below avg coach. Brees had the same team issue but one of the greatest offensive minds ever. I'd take Rodgers over any other QB. Only downside to me is his durability.
He has had wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy better defenses and supporting casts than Brees for most years. And again, lost at home. Like the season they were 14-2 or 15-1, whatever it was. That team was sick.