These days, it seems everything Peter J. Tomasi writes is gold. He should've never been taken off of Superman, but I'm very excited to see his run on Detective Comics.
Yes, Tomasi is good. It was pretty faithful to the original comics storyline, so the groundwork was already laid out for him. It did feel a little hurried, though. I know the DC animated movies aren't usually really long, but this is a story that I wish they had fleshed out a bit more.