Inside the trenches: How Sheldon Rankins is adding value to the Saints defensive line [Film Study]

More context:
-4th in forced fumbles (19)
-T7th in sacks (42)
-Held opponents to a 66.3 and 69.9 QB Rating in the 3rd and 4th QTRs
-1st in pass deflections
-13th in rushing TDs allowed (11)
-12th in passing TDs allowed (22)
-7th in Passer Rating allowed (79.0)

Some of their problem areas (penalties - 19th, YPC 28th) are issues the team focused on fixing. So far this year they are 4th in YPC allowed (3.4) and 4th in fewest penalties (11).
There were some inconsistency issues with last year's young team as well (as noted by FBO's variance mark: 2017 DEFENSE EFFICIENCY RATINGS | Football Outsiders), but they were an above average team in the NFL. I think you kind of point out several of the reasons why those yardage numbers go up. The Saints built leads and went into prevent defense mode. They focused more on eating clock than they did preventing yardage. Now, the effectiveness of this strategy can be debated, but as a team defense they were very good, especially in comparison to recent New Orleans teams.

First in pass deflections? Leaning on that doesn't help you. Stick with the meaningful stats.

10th in points, 13th in rushing TDs allowed, 12th in passing TDs allowed....those are all your best numbers, and you're about 1/3 from the top of the whole league in them. That's "good," not "very good". And you're cherry picking. The 2017 defense was a big improvement over the 2012-2016 toxic wasteland that cost Brees five years of his career, but that's faint praise. And they had a nice stretch in mid-season where they were "very good." But you've got some serious confirmation bias going on.

Peace out.