Red Dead Redemption

Also, the dude in the video says you have to use a bow to get a perfect pelt, but I don't think that's true. Some animals, alligators for example, are not one hit head kills with a bow. But you can one hit head shot them with a long range rifle.

I killed a deer with the bow, one shot to the head, and it gave me a 1 start (poor) pelt.