The Legend of Carr took a hit last Night

BooBirdSaint said
IMO we fall in love with these UDFA skill players too often. I hope we are seeing that in most cases they are UDFAs for a reason. TLL, Carr, Kirkwood and Arnold dont scare anyone defensively. They just lack the talent to be frontline guys. All those players I mentioned are fine 4 or 5th options at WRs but not 2s or 3s.
Of course it is only the injuries to Ginn and Meredith that have thrust them into this position. We need Ginn back in the worst way.

I agree mostly.

Kirkwood has the talent to be a #2 WR. He's a physical freak and he's getting open consistently. But it's the drops, the mistakes on lining up, the mess up on the pick, etc. that are holding him back.

Often, you'll have an UDFA who's got the traits but it's the details that hold them back. Sometimes it's fixable. Other times, their inability to grasp the details is why they were an UDFA in the first place.