I love to read, but I could never get through:
Jane Eyre
Watership Down
Yes I know they are beloved classics, but I stopped in the middle of both and I've barely read a book I didn't like in some way.
Others that I have finished, but didn't quite care for as much as their hype:
The Great Gatsby
Brave New World
Again, I know people love these books, some even consider Gatsby to be one of the best, but it was meh to me.