Westhoff believes that Taysom Hill will be the Saints’ starting quarterback

Yes, a person who thinks that a guy who never threw for more than 3,000 yards in college, went undrafted and has never started an NFL game is a valid comparison to a Heisman winning QB and NFL MVP is definitely someone we should take seriously enough to start a new thread about.

while I agree with you that the jury is out on what Taysom is capable in a full capacity role at QB, I think that all of your reasoning is extremely short sited. There are far far too many examples where the college skins on the wall were no indicator of what kind of pro QB they will be.