Burrow in and Brees Out: The Big What if Thread

I say no. Just because top rookie quarterbacks with all the pressure as being the first rounder don't do well the first season. You can look at him in his first season at LSU. It takes time and sometimes it takes years.

Just depends on the team around the rookie QB. Most starting rookies play for terrible teams, but that wouldn’t be the case here. Didn’t Roethlisberger win the SB in his rookie season?