I agree he’s terribly anti clutch, I disagree tho that he’s ever great in any aspect of the game. Perhaps it’s scheme. Many secondary players struggle with us over the years and do well elsewhere.
HOnestly, I think it's just that FS's get judged WAY WAY harder than any position other than QB. A LB misses a tackle and there's 5 other guys behind him to make the tackle and it's an extra 4 or 5 yards. A FS misses a tackle and there's nobody behind him so it's 6 points. All defenders miss tackles.
We hear this safety is great, that safety is elite... if they were on our team and we seen all the plays they lose and the points given up because of them? We'd all strongly disagree with them being great or elite.
But I will admit, when Williams screws up, it's been very high profile and detrimental to our season... even season ending a couple times. Poor guy...