Which of these two guards would you bring back?

Definitely Carl Nicks
My humble opinion is he is the greatest player at that position in Saints history

? agree.
I figured I’d be the only one to think that tho.
To me if he had stayed healthy he’d have gone down as one of the greatest guards in NFL history.

Big strong and mean. Things our current left guard lacks imo. I’d pick Carl in a bar fight and I’d pick Andrus as a library partner.