Which of these two guards would you bring back?

I believe so too. And iirc we got him in the 5th. Character concerns. Also got Jahri in the 4th I think.

That is correct. He was arrested just before the draft for "remaining after being forbidden" . The PoPo shut down a college party and he stayed.
Imagine that, a college kid partying.
I think he was graded as a lower 1st - upper 2nd round talent but fell into the fifth round and right into the Saint's lap