Eli sucks he is over hype juz cuz he comes from a family with football legends but he would be a great back up...his brother really needs to show him the ropes
No, the Giants suck as an organization. They have failed to draft offensive playmakers to give Eli something to work with.
Peyton looks as good as he does because Bill Polian brings/brought in players like Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark, Joesph Addai and Edgerrin James.
Peyton has been missing Marvin Harrison for much of this season, and look at his stats and the Colts' offensive struggles.
In addition, Polian has brought in quality defensive players like Bob Sanders and Dwight Freeney that are consistent playmakers.
The Short Attention Span-laden NY media/Giants fanbase seems to forget that Phil Simms looked pretty sorry until they started giving him some quality playmakers to work with. He rewarded Giants fans with the greatest completion percentage ever in a Super Bowl in Super Bowl XXI