John Kasay’s kickoff out of bounds, Panthers vs Patriots, Super Bowl XXXVIII
It’s not as dramatic as a missed FG, which raised the question of whether Kasay was anxious or just complacent. But this moment hits the top 10 because it occurred in a Super Bowl and had huge implications. I mean, how hard is it to kick the ball inbounds? I’m pretty sure most of us would be able to kick the ball in bounds. Kasay did the only thing that he COULDN’T afford to do, and it costed his team big.