Hill vs Siemian why is there a debate?

Well now the dog has caught the car so to speak. We'll see if those microscopes still works if Hill struggles should he get the nod from Payton. It won't be hard to spot the excuses. Can't complain about the offensive line and can't complain about the WR's. That's been done to no avail.
Oh, but that's going to need to be a two-way application, right? Will the people who complained about the O-line and the team's having middle school level WRs with Winston at the helm grant Taysom (or Trevor) those same caveats?