Hill vs Siemian why is there a debate?

meily said

Hill NEVER looked like he was the starter in comparison to Winston it was all semantics. Siemian entered the game and executed the offense something we've seen Hill do before but Siemian showed touch and an ability to find a passing window and though only one game appeared to scan the field and get and find his second, third and even fourth reads.

This offense does not need a super star quarterback to win, just a heady player with a natural natural feel for the passing game.

There are some aspects (not a shot against Winston) of Seimians game that made the offense flow naturally with his touch and pocket presence that makes people want to see more of him.

He gets the ball in the playmakers hands and that's really what Payton wants from his quarterbacks

Click to expand...

Siemian appears to throw the ball where the receiver can catch it with confidence to then get YAC. This is one of the best attributes a QB can have. If a receiver has to wait on the pass, he will have happy feet and lose momentum in his route. One of the things with Winston was, receivers had to be similar to a middle infielder, in baseball. The receiver never knew if the ball was coming low and left, low and right, at the feet, at the head, high and left, high and right, or wherever. Receivers were like walking on eggshells to catch Winston’s throws. It is what it is. Winston is not an accurate passer, but he is/was better then Hill. With Siemian, and from what I saw, he processes the coverage very quick and throws a pass with great ball placement for the receiver to catch. Similar attributes to Drew. Let me say this though. HE IS NOT DREW! HE IS NOT WINSTON! But I think, he is our best option on the roster. Especially, considering how Hill helps the offense, in his joler role. Hill is the BEST and the most unique talent in the history of the NFL, for what he does. No one even close in the history of the league. Not even today. Teams are trying to find the next Hill, but none on the radar ATM.

All said. Please let the Hill dog to lay in his bed and allow Siemian to be the QB.