Hill vs Siemian why is there a debate?

BoxerJoe said
Everyone agreed that naming Winston the starter was the right call and that he won the job fair and square.

I disagree. Maybe you missed the whole thread about Hill should request a trade and that the QB competition was unfair to Hill. Not everyone agreed that naming Winston the starter was the right call and definitely not everyone thought he won the job fair and sqare

BoxerJoe said
That doesn't mean you can't root for Taysom to come in and light it up.

I never said I wasn't going to root for Hill to light it up. I simply said I won't accept bad Oline play or WR's not getting open as an excuse if Hill struggles to maintain or improve the offensive performance.

BoxerJoe said
It also doesn't mean you can't/shouldn't stay consistent with evaluating the QB's performance.

Oh I plan to be as consistent as the crowd that has been critical of Winston these first 6 games have been.