It’s amazing how many people know nothing about Hill as a QB, they just like the player and that he’s a team player and very likable guy.
The truth is, Hill wasn’t a good “passing” QB in college and while he’s better now, he still isn’t good. He’s yet to learn how to successfully and continually go through progressions (we saw what happened when given that chance against Philly), he doesn’t throw receivers open (they have to be wide open which won’t happen often with this receiving Corp), etc.
I honestly admire Payton’s loyalty, it’s admirable and it’s one of the many reasons almost every player loves playing for him. Just make sure that loyalty and even a little bit of arrogance doesn’t kill the team.
If he goes with Hill, he’s plenty good enough to beat the bad teams with our defense, but with no MT to bail him out I don’t see him being close to a QB that will win a playoff game or have us deep in the playoffs.