Hill vs Siemian why is there a debate?
That's just the type of hypocrisy I am talking about. Jameis supporters want to hold Taysom supporters to task over being as critical with Taysom as they were with Jameis, but Jameis supporters don't want to be held to task of explaining away things for Taysom like they did for Jameis.
No, I respectfully disagree. First and foremost, I'm not going to separate people into groups of Jameis and Hill supporters. I support what I feel is best for the team.
I think you mischaracterize people who defended Winston's play. Those folks, including myself, felt it wasn't fair to Winston to judge his play with complete disregard to the injuries to the Oline and the inexperience of the WR group and that was it. Very few people were overlooking unwise decisions that Winston made where he got lucky and didn't hurt the team.
The people who were being overly critical of Winston refused to take that into consideration and actually used that as a basis for being critical of Winston. It would be the height of hypocrisy to now take those into consideration to excuse any mistakes made by Hill.
I explained my reasonings previously. No, I intend to apply the same standards previously set by those who were critical of Winston's play. It's not necessary to take into consideration Oline injuries or WR talent to evaluate Hill. If he can't maintain the offensive production and keep the TO's to a minimum then by the standard that has been set, it's his fault and his shortcomings as a QB that will be responsible.
You don't get to claim hypocrisy for using previously established metrics. if it was acceptable to criticize Winston and disregard those things, it will be acceptable to criticize Hill and disregard those things. It's as simple as that. And if the people who were critical of Winston suddenly go quiet, THEN you will have the hypocrisy you mentioned.
Your saying, "I'm going to act like Taysom supporters by not allowing excuses" is no different that a Taysom supporter saying, "I'm going to act like Jameis supporters and excuse away every bad thing of Taysom under the sun."
I'm saying I'm going to apply the same standard that has been established for being critical of the QB position this year. Nothing more, nothing less.