Hill vs Siemian why is there a debate?

The debate should be about QB ability and effectiveness in this offense going forward. Up until he got hurt, Jameis was the QB with the most of both. Now, with Trevor and Taysom as the only choices - which has more ability and effectiveness?
Before I start this, I am NOT a Taysom hater. Nor do I think Trevor is a great QB.
That being said, who of the 2 QBs has the most positive traits that result in effectiveness on the field.
Taysom, in the way Payton is using him, isn’t as effective as Trevor. Taysom is indecisive, holds onto the ball too long, can’t read defenses, is turnover prone, and has no deep ball. Trevor, by comparison, is decisive, has pocket awareness, can read defenses, actually has touch on his passes, and actually can throw a deep pass.
Trevor has much more experience at the QB position, and it shows.
This isn’t a debate. Trevor wins as a better option going forward for this season.