Hill vs Siemian why is there a debate?

Didn't he test the FA waters once and didn't get a bite? Not many coaches can utilize him as well as SP, and no one is going to pay him more than us just to come in and be a back up.
The Saints gave him a nice contract the day Drew retired so I don't think there was a chance for many offers this year, maybe last year when the 1st round waiver was on him.