If he is there, do you draft McFadden?

Nooooooooo.

McFadden may be a terrific NFL player, but you rarely get value picking a running back that high and we've already got too much money invested in the backfield. We won't get as good of a player as McFadden later in the draft (obviously), but we can get someone with MUCH better value. We don't need a gamebreaker, we have one (I'm counting on a bounceback year from Reggie). We just need someone reliable, and we might have that in Pierre (if Deuce comes back to form, even better). Those guys are easy to find.

We're blessed to have such a high pick with a 7-9 record. To use it on a RB given our other needs just seems like a waste, no matter how good he is.