The players know who the players are is so true. We can debate, and a lot of us are simply going off our tastes. Guitar playing is less about true precision in playing, more about emotion and the feeling of the music being played. Which is why I’ve always thought Rhodes was so amazing. He had the technical skill, but could still let out a fury of emotion off his playing. Kinda why I never liked Clapton. Technically a great guitarist but boring as can be. Page when not strung out had the technical ability but went for emotional sound. Feel the same about Jack White. Lots of the time in the White Stripes a musical mess, but an musical power. But when he wants, plays wonderful technically correct music