Compare the 2009 and 2022 Saints Rosters

SaintsMan209 said

crazy how so many of 09 are way better. i would take deverey in the super bowl season over Olave any day, and say as Lance Moore over Landry. I'd take Colston over Mike Thomas until Thomas wins a SB. Also, Will Smith in his prime is better than Cam Jordan in his prime. But Cam has longevitiy over Will.

Click to expand...

I was with you until you said Mike Thomas needs to win a Superbowl before he gets the crown over Colston. There’s absolutely no way Marques Colston could pull off the season MT had in 2019. And by your standard, no one on the 2022 roster would be ranked higher than any of the ‘09 players. I’m not sure that’s fair.

And I love Will Smith. He’s the second-best DE in Saints history. But for various reasons, his production was inconsistent. Cam Jordan is solidly & unquestionably #1 all-time.