Chrissy Simms top 40 QB Ranking (Updates till completion)

livefromDC said

Nah. This is Phil Simms' kid we're talking about. I don't think Drew Brees even cracked his top 10 during his last 5 seasons in the league. The guy has a huge irrational dislike for anything Saints. I could easily see him moving Winston from #26 to #23 after a deep playoff run because... reasons.

Click to expand...

He doesn't hate the Saints. During the years he gave critique of Brees & MT, he was constantly fawning over Sean Payton's coaching.

I've listened to Chris Simms for a few years. There are two things that have huge impact on how he evaluates. He likes QBs who have big arms. And he likes WRs/CBs who can fly down the field. These aren't the only factors, obviously. But in his mind if there's a QB or WR who can do everything else at an elite level but they lack that one thing, he will always devalue them in relation to how others view that player. It's as simple as that.