Do y'all agree with this take on Ceedy?

That’s in the past. But what’s in the future is CGJ’s contract, and so far we have given two big contracts to personality red flags.
You want to "forget about the past," but it seems you're holding the "past" against MT. And I think what everyone wants to know (at least I do) is what exactly you mean by "red flags" regarding the personalities of MT and CGJ; it would be useful to get some meat on the bone by what exactly you mean here.

Maybe if you fleshed this point out a bit, your concern would be better understood.