At this time he isn't the highest rated player, not even one of them. Their defense is seriously getting older, and we all know that Parcells is going to want to start to work on the defense. So with Parcells wanting to do that, I'm really expecting to look at Chris Long or Glenn Dorsey - two of the top rated players.
Besides, it wasn't just Miami that had Beck rated highly. Many teams seemed to think that he would be NFL ready much more quickly than any of the other top QBs. He has been compared to a bigger, taller version of Drew Brees - which can't be bad.
Another thing to think about, is the fact that drafting two QBs in back to back years would have serious implications on their future cap space. It's not like they are close to being a great team anyway, I think they should give Beck a chance for a while, yet at the same time building the rest of the team up. In a year or two, if Beck isn't the answer - then start to think of grabbing a QB.