Carr just leaves me with a big ol fat meh, it doesn't move the excitement needle one way or another with me. You get him at max for 5 years and pray the wheels don't start falling off by year 3. I would still draft a QB even if we get Carr.
I think Carr is a talented QB and is an outstanding leader. We can't underestimate the intangibles. Do I think he wins games for us? I'd say we would have been plus 2-3 games last year. That would have gotten us to the dance.
I'd be excited to have him in the black and gold. Otherwise another year with Andy (believe it or not it could be much worse) and hopefully we draft and develop a QB of the future.