Back row, left to right:
Browns - Milt Plum (Frankie Ryan would take over in 1962)
Steelers - Bobby Layne, I think (yep, Layne)
Cardinals - Sam Etcheverry
Bears - Billy Wade
Packers - Bart Starr
Colts - Johnny Unitas
Washington - Norm Snead
Rams - Zeke Bratkowski
Front row, left to right:
Lions - Jim Ninowski
Vikings - Fran Tarkenton
Cowboys - Don Meredith
49ers - John Brodie? (yep, Brodie)
Eagles - Sonny Jurgensen
Giants - The Bald Eagle, Y.A. Tittle