Have you watched the All-22 of every single one of Carr's and Winston's plays since they've been in the NFL? I ask because you've never posted the All-22 of every single one of Carr's or Winston's plays.
What you've posted of Carr's and Winston's plays is a very small percentage of all of their plays. It should not surprise anyone that the small percentage of their plays that you have posted always seem to support what you are saying.
You're not going to post any videos, or stats for that matter, that don't support what you're saying. Most people wouldn't.
Bottom line, I'll always put more stock in the evaluations from NFL professionals over the evaluations of anyone on any fan site who isn't an active or retired NFL professional.
Can you show 3 current or former NFL professionals that currently have Winston graded as high or higher than Carr?