Saints and Carr deal released $150M over 4 years $100M fully guaranteed

They’re not facts. They’re your opinion (from, as you said, watching him). Which you’re welcome to.
The fact was that a qb desperate team let Carr walk. The fact was he got benched during his most recent season. The third fact was Dalton out performed him when the Raiders and Saints played in 2022. Fourth he was shutout when Raiders played Saints.
My hope is that he does great. My opinion is that many people or overhyping him.