{2023 Thread Bumped} Underhill Giving No Quarter to Nick Wright

Actually, maybe they can. Every year or two the cap goes up. So by pushing dead money back you are paying salary later for cheaper. It’s like using your mortgage to pay off credit card money. Not only do you get a much lower interest rate but you spread the money over many years.

Businesses do this all the time. Even very profitable corporations will take a loan (or sell bonds) to spread expense over years so they have more cash today.

The problem with Wright’s take is (1) the Saints definitely signed Carr knowing these cuts were coming and so all this needs to be thought of as one move, not a desperate decision by a team wanting to win now, and (2) they actually got Carr at a good price. QBs cost $30 M a year these days, end of story. So if the Saints wanted a starter, this had to be done. It wasn’t a reckless move, it was a team that didn’t want to waste a year tanking only to miss out on the QB they wanted because someone traded up. The DLs they released can be replaced with FAs. Those three simply aren’t that good.

This is tangential to the original post, but since you mentioned tanking...My biggest pet peeve with the national media takes on the Saints is all the analytic types act as if tanking is conclusively the best way to build a championship team. But for as much as they condescendingly claim to be more data-driven than philistine fans...what data is there to indicate tanking is the best way to do it?

In the past decade in the three major sports, the Astros and Cubs successfully turned a complete tank into a championship (2 for HOU). But the Chiefs, Rams, Buccaneers, Patriots did not tank. The Warriors, Milwaukee Bucks, Lakers, Raptors (all-in for a 1/2 season rental of Kawhi) did not tank. The Braves, Dodgers, Red Sox, and Nationals did not tank. And if we were to throw up our hands and tank/"take our medicine" our division is too bad for us to get Caleb Williams next year even if we had Dalton running an option offense and Dennis Allen doing keg stands before games.

Plus, the Browns went all-in on accumulating high-value draft picks in the early 2010s when Mike Lombardi ran the team and what did it get them? Nothing. Ralph Malbrough of WWL pointed out the Jets twice drafted a QB in the top 5 of the draft in the past 5 years and are now desperately trying to get a vet QB. The 76ers were everyone's darling for "The Process" and they didn't get out of the 2nd round of the playoffs (even if they win this year, I'm not even sure it counts as "The Process" since they ditched that several years ago and Embiid is the only one of their 4 top-5 picks who panned out for them).

Anyway, thank you for coming to my TED talk.