Haener film looks better than Young.

Really? Also, did you take into account the quality of opponents? My concern with Haener is that when I see him, he just seems so small (and a very small frame). He looks even smaller than Young to me. I am excited to see him in the preseason, but some seem to be expecting a lot out him him right away.
While Haener did not play against Georgia or TN. or LSU he also did not have GA,TN, or LSU's talent at O line or WR's or even RB's. The quality of the opponent goes along with the quality of the team around you. If you swap Young with Haener I would bet cash $ he would have been a top 10 pick