PFF - have y'all seen this

TribuneUK said

Ah now that's a shame, you managed a brief flirtation with honesty back on page 5 (with some help) and admitted that you think Jameis should start over Carr, but now you've gone back to the old act.

I'll just revert to observing that you're clearly going to continue questioning the quality of any other Saints QB not called Jameis, not because it's evidential fact, but because you can't let go of your vision of Jameis being a starter for this team.

Click to expand...

Nope...my "honesty" is since DA has a specific offense in mind, he should play whoever fits/plays in that system better. It's not a hard concept to get and I clearly stated this.
If he wants to run an offense similar to that of a "broken" Brees, Carr would be the better fit, as that's the system he has played in majority of his career. If he wanted to run something similar to the offense up until 2015 or the offense that Carr just left, Jameis would be the better fit, as those were the offenses that he ran in college and the league.

And what quality did I question? I asked a simple question that no one has been able to answer; what makes Carr an upgrade over Dalton or Winston? If you can't answer this without reference to a line from Underhill or Ross, then you honestly don't know.
He is Saints QB1 and I'm rocking with him but I've always viewed him as a side grade and I said that from the get go. It's crazy how you want to listen to pundits and front offices when they talk about any other QB but when those same people don't bask in the rays the sunshine pumpers are pushing, then it is fingers in ears.

But again, my post is about football; yours seem to come from "feelings."