i dont look at it from a standpoint of being right.
As US fans, we have a consistent tendency to "anoint" a player WELL before that player has had the ability to round out his game. Dude is 19. Hasnt seen major competition at an elite level, with consistency, yet. Lets see where he is 2 years from now. IF he is THAT good, he would already be in Europe instead of San Jose- and in 31 appearances with SJ, he has 3 goals. THREE. So all im saying is pump the brakes. If he was "that guy" - he would already be showing off his talent abroad.
Look no further than Pepi- raw talent works in the Gold Cup - but i bet Pepi would tell you that he is still attempting to add the finishing touches to his game. Let them find thier way, then play and we can see what happens.